If you’re looking for a spooky story, look no further! The Resurrection of Evania James is a chilling Gothic suspense guaranteed to make you gasp in horror as you double check that all your doors are locked tight at night. Featuring grave robbing, insane asylums, mansions full of secrets, and a charming Irish rogue, this novel is a must-have for Gothic suspense fans.
Main Themes
In 1897, Eloise James is horrified when her father sends her sister, Evania, to an asylum. When Evania disappears, Eloise is determined to get answers, but the accounts of her disappearance and purported death don’t line up. When she runs into Silas Dobbs, a wannabe Irish journalist, his theories of grave robbers, underground resurrectionists, and dark secrets hidden in the asylum terrify her. She doesn’t want to believe that these things are true, but the more she dares to defy her cruel father and search for the truth, the more sinister facts she finds. But when her father threatens to put her in the same asylum her sister went missing from, Eloise has to decide if the truth is worth fighting for. Will she become the kind and courageous person God made her to be, or will her father’s cruelty keep her small and ignorant forever?
In the present day time thread, Tilly just moved into James Mansion with her grandfather, who has early stage Alzheimer’s. When she discovers a body hidden in the walls, she is also determined to get answers. But her journey for the truth involves a high school crush that went south and insecurities about her own value. As the search for answers drudges up dark secrets that were never meant to see the light of day, Tilly realizes that life has far more layers than she was prepared for.
The Resurrection of Evania James wrestles with difficult questions such as what honoring parents should like when they are abusive and demeaning, the history of resurrectionists and grave robbing in America, and giving people a chance to show that they have changed and grown past childhood mistakes.
Favorite Scenes
Silas Dobbs, with his fun accent and roguish confidence, was definitely my favorite character. His support is instrumental in helping Eloise discover the truth and figure out what she wants her life to look like apart from her father’s suffocating restrictions and harsh words.
Faith Elements
Both Eloise and Tilly struggle with trusting God and having the courage to act out of faith rather than fear. Silas helps Eloise wrestle through the question of what the verse “honor thy father and mother” looks like in a broken world.
Family Friendly Considerations
There are quite a few creepy suspense elements that might be overwhelming for more sensitive readers, but for fans of Gothic suspense, this relatively clean read will be delightfully thrilling without being gross or ghost-dependent. There are brief descriptions of the methods used by resurrections are that disturbing in nature, but the novel does not dwell on those scenes. There is also some domestic abuse, as well as questions about women’s rights (or lack thereof in the 1800s), addiction recovery, and aging grandparents. While romance is hinted at, the plot is focused on solving the mystery of Evania’s disappearance.
Interested in Similar Reads?
If you enjoy dual-timelines with plenty of suspense and mild horror, you’ll want to check out these novels as well:
- Daughters of the Wreckage by Stefanie Koens
- The Lumber Baron’s Wife by Lynn Austin
- The Wings of Poppy Pendleton by Melanie Dobson
FamilyFiction received a complimentary final copy of this novel from Bethany House Publishers. This review is the personal opinion of Kaylisa M.
