Lizzie Anne and Samuel have
decided to get married, and Lindsay — about to be baptized in the
Amish faith — is courting Matthew. While Katie Kauffman is happy for
her friends who seem to have settled their futures, she is also finding
herself something of a fifth wheel. When Lindsay’s sister Jessica
returns to Bird-in-Hand, she finds that Jake Miller has moved on with
his life. He lost hope that Jessica would ever be satisfied to settle in
rural Pennsylvania and takes comfort in becoming close friends with
Katie. However, it’s not an easy road as Jake is Mennonite and Katie has
just been baptized in the Amish faith. Her father forbids them to see
each other, adamant that his daughter marry an Amish man …